Información General

• Autores: Manuel Aragón Reyes (ed. lit.), Enrique Gimbernat Ordeig (ed. lit.), Agustín Ruiz Robledo (ed. lit.)
• Editores: Colex
• Año de publicación: 2024
• País: España
• Idioma: inglés
• ISBN: 978-84-1194-485-4
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)

Resumen

• This book arose from the perplexity of its three promoters: hearing a significant number of proponents of amnesty (whether politicians, journalists, or jurists) claim that the majority of jurists were expressing support for its constitutionality and that the few who did not were presenting very weak arguments. As this was not the impression they held, they set out to compile opinions contrary to the constitutionality of amnesty. The result proved remarkable: over sixty highly respected authors contributed 78 critical texts concerning the amnesty arising from the PSOE-Junts pact. Readers are invited to assess the quality of the arguments presented and to pursue their enquiries regarding the number of jurists who have defended amnesty. To us, the balance seems clear in terms of both the sheer number of jurists and the strength of the arguments.

  To address amnesty in the most comprehensive manner possible, the book is divided into five legal chapters and a sixth from broader perspectives:

  – An overview of the Rule of Law in Spain after the July 2023 elections.

  – The general unconstitutionality of amnesty.

  – The Spanish amnesty from the point of view of european law.

  – The parliamentary bill for an Organic Law on amnesty for institutional, political and social normalisation in Catalonia.

  – The harassment of judges.

  – Five outlooks beyond the law.

Otros catálogos

• Red de Bibliotecas Universitarias (REBIUN)

Listado de artículos

• • An overview of the rule of law in spain after the july 2023 elections

    • Legal constructivism?

      Manuel Aragón Reyes

      págs. 21-24

      

    • Puigdemont and the Constitution

      Xavier Arbós i Marín

      págs. 25-28

      

    • Who cares?

      Andrés Betancor Rodríguez

      págs. 29-36

      

    • The deconstruction of the law by the contract

      José Esteve Pardo

      págs. 37-42

      

    • Is the rule of law in Spain in crisis?

      Teresa Freixes Sanjuán

      págs. 43-48

      

    • Rule of law and amnesty

      Antonio Manuel Peña Freire

      págs. 49-54

      

    • Is president Sánchez leading a new constitutional theory?

      Agustín Ruiz Robledo

      págs. 55-59

      

  • The general unconstitutionality of the amnesty. 1. The unconstitutionality of any amnesty in the light of the Spanish Constitution in force

    • The Constitution does not allow amnesty

      Manuel Aragón Reyes

      págs. 65-68

      

    • Amnesty in our legal system

      José Luis Díez Ripollés

      págs. 69-74

      

    • General pardons and amnesties

      Enrique Gimbernat Ordeig

      págs. 75-78

      

    • If the Government wants to grant amnesty to Puigdemont it must reform the Constitution

      María Inmaculada Ramos Tapia, Agustín Ruiz Robledo

      págs. 79-86

      

    • Forgetting and forgiveness in the Constitution

      Miguel Ángel Recuerda Girela

      págs. 87-90

      

    • Unconstitutional amnesty

      Fernando Simón Yarza

      págs. 91-94

      

    • Constitutional State and amnistía

      Javier Tajadura Tejada

      págs. 95-100

      

    • On whether the amnesty law violates the rule of law

      Rodrigo Tena

      págs. 101-104

      

    • Amnesty á la carte

      Salvador Viada Bardají

      págs. 105-108

      

    • The amnesty and the bear of professor Recaséns

      Virgilio Zapatero Gómez

      págs. 109-113

      

  • The general unconstitutionality of the amnesty. 2. Amnesty in history and in the Cortes Generales

    • Amnesty was not regulated in the Spanish Constitution on purpose

      Ibor Fernandes Romero

      págs. 117-122

      

    • Amnesty and the serfs of the gloss

      Pablo de Lora Deltoro

      págs. 123-128

      

    • Memory, amnesty and transition

      Josu de Miguel Bárcena

      págs. 129-135

      

    • Amnesty as a painful anachronism

      Juan Antonio Ortega y Díaz-Ambrona

      págs. 135-140

      

    • Conditional amnesty

      Miguel Satrústegui Gil-Delgado

      págs. 141-146

      

  • The general unconstitutionality of the amnesty. 3. Amnesty in the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court

    • Amnesty in the doctrine of the spanish courts

      Alvaro Redondo Hermida

      págs. 149-152

      

    • Does the Constitutional Court uphold the amnesty?

      Agustín Ruiz Robledo

      págs. 153-159

      

  • The general unconstitutionality of the amnesty. 4. Prerequisites for an amnesty law

    • Amnesty, the power and not the truth

      Daniel Berzosa López

      págs. 163-168

      

    • Politics, democracy and exceptionality: a look from the statement of reasons for the parliamentary bill of amnesty

      Josep Maria Castellà Andreu

      págs. 169-176

      

    • An arbitrary amnesty

      Javier Delgado Barrio

      págs. 177-180

      

    • An amnesty without legal basis

      Alicia Gil Gil

      págs. 181-186

      

    • Amnesty? Not one, but three questions

      Juan Antonio Lascuraín Sánchez

      págs. 187-194

      

    • The public interest in amnesty

      Gonzalo Quintero Olivares

      págs. 195-198

      

    • That's no way to go

      José María Ruiz Soroa

      págs. 199-202

      

    • No reasons for an amnesty

      Jesús María Silva Sánchez

      págs. 203-206

      

    • Amnesty, or if you have to change, you change

      Virgilio Zapatero Gómez

      págs. 207-210

      

  • The general unconstitutionality of the amnesty. 5. Discussion of the reasons put forward in favour of the constitutionality of the amnesty

    • The amnesty fallacy

      Manuel Atienza Rodríguez

      págs. 213-216

      

    • Amnesty and academic lackeys

      Alfonso Jaime García Figueroa

      págs. 217-220

      

    • Criticism of the Sumar legal opinion on amnesty

      Enrique Gimbernat Ordeig

      págs. 221-224

      

    • The illegitimate amnesty (or the problem of the absence of aconstitutional enabling clause

      Manuel Martínez Sospedra

      págs. 225-230

      

    • Beccaria, amnesty and progress

      Agustín Ruiz Robledo

      págs. 231-235

      

  • The spanish amnesty from the point of view of european law

    • The Constitution, Spain and Europe

      Antonio Bar Cendón

      págs. 239-244

      

    • Amnesty before the Venice Commission

      Belén Becerril Atienza

      págs. 245-248

      

    • Amnesty law: the spanish judge and the EU

      Jaime Lozano Ibáñez

      págs. 249-254

      

    • Will europe save us from ourselves?

      Araceli Mangas Martín

      págs. 255-262

      

    • Junts' conditions and his idea of law

      Gonzalo Quintero Olivares

      págs. 263-266

      

    • The european case law on amnesty

      Alvaro Redondo Hermida

      págs. 267-270

      

    • “Economic” amnesty and european law

      Francisco Javier Roldán Barbero

      págs. 271-276

      

    • Amnesty from the Council of Europe

      Rafael Rubio Núñez

      págs. 277-284

      

  • The parliamentary bill for an organic law on amnesty for institutional, political and social normalisation in Catalonia

    • The parliamentary bill for Amnesty and the rule of law

      Segismundo Alvarez Royo-Villanova

      págs. 285-290

      

    • A fallacious amnesty

      Manuel Aragón Reyes

      págs. 291-294

      

    • Amnesty: a law of full stop... And after

      Roberto Luis Blanco Valdés

      págs. 295-300

      

    • The procés continues: now it’s time for amnesty

      Francesc de Carreras Serra

      págs. 301-304

      

    • Again on the unconstitutionality of the amnesty

      Vicente Conde Martín de Hijas

      págs. 305-308

      

    • Why this amnesty does not fit into our constitutional system

      Francisco Javier Díaz Revorio

      págs. 309-316

      

    • Amnesty: the reasons for unreason

      Tomás-Ramón Fernández Rodríguez

      págs. 317-320

      

    • Amnesty and Constitutional Court

      Germán Fernández Farreres

      págs. 321-324

      

    • Amnesty?

      José Antonio García-Trevijano Garnica

      págs. 325-330

      

    • Criticism of the Parliamentary Bill Organic Amnesty Law

      Enrique Gimbernat Ordeig

      págs. 331-338

      

    • An undiscussed and arbitrary amnesty law

      José Joaquín Jiménez Sánchez

      págs. 339-342

      

    • The unjustification of the amnesty under the proportionality principle

      David Martínez Zorrilla

      págs. 343-348

      

    • The Secretary General of Congress and the Parliamentary Bill Organic Law on Amnesty

      Elisa de la Nuez Sánchez-Cascado

      págs. 349-353

      

    • The amnesty law: persuading, but not convincing

      Fabio Pascua Mateo

      págs. 353-360

      

    • A monstrous self-amnesty

      Luis Rodríguez Ramos

      págs. 361-366

      

    • The spectre of amnesty materialises in an unconstitutional law

      Agustín Ruiz Robledo

      págs. 367-374

      

    • I confess... That i don’t understand anything

      Remedio Sánchez Ferriz

      págs. 375-378

      

    • Law of impunity: an x-ray of the parliamentary bill for an organic law on amnesty for institutional, political and social normalisation in Catalonia

      Germán M. Teruel Lozano

      págs. 379-384

      

    • The clumsy cause of amnesty

      Jesús Manuel Villegas Fernández

      págs. 385-387

      

  • The harassment of judges

    • “The war of [against] the judges“

      Antonio Bar Cendón

      págs. 391-396

      

    • The degradation of the rule of law and false lawfare

      Vicente Garrido Mayol

      págs. 397-404

      

    • Judges in Berlin

      Juan Antonio Lascuraín Sánchez

      págs. 405-408

      

    • Amnesty and lawfare: make-up and euphemism

      Gerardo Pérez Sánchez

      págs. 409-412

      

    • Amnesty: the Trojan horse against the Constitution

      Jorge Rodríguez-Zapata y Pérez

      págs. 413-416

      

    • Lawfare and political neolanguage

      Jesús María Silva Sánchez

      págs. 417-420

      

    • The architect of ruins

      Francisco Sosa Wagner, Mercedes Fuertes López

      págs. 420-426

      

    • Exhibition with no reason for amnesty

      Jesús María Zarzalejos Nieto

      págs. 427-430

      

  • Five outlooks beyond the law

    • Apology for betrayal: reward for guilt

      Juan Luis Cebrián

      págs. 433-436

      

    • Progressive majority?

      Adela Cortina Orts

      págs. 437-442

      

    • A constitutional rebellion

      Antonio Elorza

      págs. 443-448

      

    • Expediency, cheating and blackmail

      Daniel Gascón

      págs. 453-456