Resumen de Length-Tension Differences Between Concentric and Eccentric Shoulder Rotation Strength
Kevin A. Giordano, Molly Cich, Gretchen D. Oliver
Eccentric contractions generally produce more force than concentric contractions. However, if length-tension relationships affect both contractions equally remains unknown. Therefore, our purpose was to compare concentric versus eccentric shoulder external and internal rotation strength across a continuous 90[degrees] arc. Fifty-two physically active individuals performed isokinetic concentric and eccentric shoulder external rotation and internal rotation through a 90[degrees] arc (forearm horizontal to forearm vertical) with the shoulder elevated in both the frontal and scapular planes. Statistical parametric mapping analysis compared concentric and eccentric trials within subjects. Frontal plane eccentric external rotation torque was greater than concentric 30[degrees]-90[degrees] (p < 0.01) external rotation, and concentric external rotation torque was greater 5[degrees]-15[degrees] external rotation (p = 0.01). Frontal plane, eccentric internal rotation torque was greater than concentric 15[degrees]-55[degrees] external rotation (p < 0.01), and concentric torque was greater at forearm horizontal (p = 0.05) and 70[degrees]-90[degrees] external rotation (p < 0.01). Scapular plane eccentric external rotation torque was greater than concentric 30[degrees]-90[degrees] external rotation (p < 0.01) and concentric external rotation torque was greater 5[degrees]-20[degrees] external rotation (p < 0.01). Scapular plane eccentric internal rotation torque was greater than concentric 15[degrees]-60[degrees] external rotation (p < 0.01), and concentric torque was greater at forearm horizontal (p = 0.05) and 78[degrees]-90[degrees] external rotation (p = 0.02). Coaches, clinicians, and researchers should interpret data from studies reporting isokinetic data with the understanding that isokinetic peak strength values are not comparing the same muscle length and are not an appropriate measure for all muscle lengths. Furthermore, shoulder stability is affected through decreased eccentric force production at end ranges of shoulder rotation.
