El Consejo General del Poder Judicial en Perspectiva: análisis, desafíos y propuesta de reforma

• Miguel Barrio, Rodrigo ^[1]
  1. [1] Universidad de Burgos

     Universidad de Burgos

     Burgos, España

     
• Localización: Revista de Derecho Político, ISSN 0211-979X, Nº 120, 2024, págs. 289-317
• Idioma: español
• Títulos paralelos:
  • The General Council of the Judiciary in Perspective: Analysis, Challenges, and Proposal for reform
• Enlaces
  • Texto completo
• Resumen
  • español

    El presente trabajo aborda la coyuntura actual que atraviesa el Consejo General del Poder Judicial, llevando a cabo un examen exhaustivo de su estructura, funciones y modalidad de designación de los vocales y funciones esenciales. De esta manera, se identifican los desafíos a los que se enfrenta dicho órgano, en especial debido a su politización, analizando el notorio carácter presidencialista, la merma de competencias y la distribución de los vocales entre los partidos políticos en base a distintas cuotas, lo que ha resultado en el actual estancamiento en su renovación. La afectación a la independencia judicial, y en particular a la imagen del Poder Judicial, se muestra evidente. La libertad otorgada por el legislador constituyente en el modelo de designación de los doce vocales provenientes del ámbito judicial ha generado inquietudes sobre su verdadera autonomía. En este sentido, se plantean reflexiones destinadas a una reforma del modelo de designación de los vocales del Consejo, retornando al modelo corporativista, con el objetivo primordial de fortalecer su independencia y legitimidad.

  • English

    The present work addresses the current situation that the Council of the Judiciary is going through, carrying out a thorough examination of its structure, functions, and modality of appointment of key members and functions. In this way, the challenges faced by this body are identified, especially due to its politicization, by analyzing the notable presidentialist nature, the reduction of powers, and the distribution of members among political parties based on different quotas, which has resulted in the current deadlock in its renewal. The impact on judicial independence, particularly on the image of the judiciary, is evident, as the freedom granted by the constituent legislator in the model of appointing the twelve members from the judicial field has raised concerns about their true autonomy. In this regard, reflections are proposed for a reform of the model for appointing Council members, with the primary objective of strengthening their independence and legitimacy.

    Summary: I. INTRODUCTION. II. A FIRST APPROACH TO THE GENERAL COUNCIL OF THE JUDICIARY. III. THE PROCESS OF APPOINTING MEMBERS OF THE GENERAL COUNCIL OF THE JUDICIARY. IV. CHALLENGES OF THE GENERAL COUNCIL OF THE JUDICIARY. IV.1 The Challenge of Politicization: Political Influences in the Judicial Body. IV.2 Analysis of Recent Modifications in the Scope of Competencies of the Council. IV.3 The Stalemate in the Renewal of the Council and its consequences. V. REFLECTIONS FOR A REFORM OF THE MODEL FOR APPOINTING THE MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL. VI. CONCLUSIONS.