Resumen de Usos do termo emoção na obra de B. F. Skinner

Heitor Vicente da Silveira, Carlos Eduardo Lopes, Henrique Mesquita Pompermaier

• English

  Although emotions are considered relevant phenomena in diverse psychologies, the concepts used in the psychological literature are divergent because they are approached by different authors in different philosophical contexts. However, Radical Behaviorism is often accused of neglecting emotions. The objective of this article was to evaluate the pertinence of these criticism. For this propose, the uses of the term emotion in Skinner’s work were searched and systematized. It was a theoretical-conceptual research carried out in three stages. The first stage consisted in selecting texts in which Skinner employed the term “emotion”, as well as similar words or expressions, such as: “emotional”, “emotive”, and so on. To do so, a search for these terms was performed using the computer’s Ctrl + F command in Skinner’s books in pdf format. The search was made from the radical “emot”. The second stage was a comparison of the uses of the term “emotion” selected in from the previous stage, in order to evaluate the continuity or rupture in Skinnerian’s treatment of the subject. Thereby, each of the identified terms and their respective sections were cut out and transcribed into tables in order to facilitate comparison. The tables contained four columns: the keyword, the section in which it appears, an interpretative comment, and the categorization according to the convergences found. In the third stage it was performed a categorization of the meanings of the term “emotion” found in Skinner’s work. This classification was made in the last column of the table described in the previous step. The uses of the terms and the elaboration of the categories attest that Skinner discuss emotions practically from the beginning to the end of his work.

  The convergences of the terms related to emotions allow to delineate a Skinnerian theory of emotions, which remains the same, even with the adoption of the operant model. In this theory, emotion is defined as an immediate and temporary change in the strength of behaviors that composes a behavioral repertoire. In this emotional state, while certain responses have a high probability of occurrence, other responses have a low probability. The only difference promoted by the operant model is that with its adoption, Skinner begins to consider that in an emotional state both reflex and operant responses occur. The occurrences of the emotional terms throughout the work contradict, therefore, the criticisms traditionally directed to the Skinnerian theory in which it ignores the importance of emotions. The difficulty in understanding the notion of state seems to be one of the reasons why Skinner’s theory of emotions is still little discussed, even in behavioral literature. The comprehension of Skinner’s theory of emotions seems to depend directly on the interpretation of the philosophical commitments of Radical Behaviorism.

• português

  A temática das emoções é discutida por praticamente toda teoria psicológica e, justamente por isso, o behaviorismo radical é criticado por supostamente ignorar as emoções. Partindo dessa crítica, o objetivo deste trabalho foi sistematizar os usos dos termos relacionados a emoções na obra skinneriana. Para tanto, o método foi dividido em três etapas. Na primeira etapa, o radical “emot” foi buscado em livros de Skinner previamente digitalizados, por meio do comando Ctrl + F do computador. Na segunda etapa os trechos que continham palavras relacionadas a emoções foram recortados e dispostos em tabelas com: palavra-chave, trecho transcrito e interpretação do trecho. A terceira etapa consistiu na categorização pela convergência de significados dos termos encontrados nas etapas anteriores. Os resultados mostram que Skinner empregou termos relacionados às emoções em todos os livros analisados, com mais frequência naqueles publicados em 1938, 1953 e 1957. Os dados obtidos foram organizados em seis categorias: estado emocional, estímulo emocional, operação emocional, reação emocional, eventos privados e padrão emocional. A articulação dessas categorias permite esboçar uma teoria skinneriana das emoções, conduzindo à conclusão de que a acusação de que o behaviorismo radical ignora as emoções não se sustenta.