Failures of Mind and Meaning

• Autores: Akeel Bilgrami
• Localización: Social research: An international quarterly of the social sciences, ISSN 0037-783X, Nº. 3, 2016 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Failure), págs. 549-571
• Idioma: inglés
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • Failure, the very idea, presupposes a norm by the lights of which it gets counted as such. And so failure, I argue, is essential to understanding the nature of norms. But I begin with a qualifying restriction. There is frequent talk of failure that presupposes something less (or other) than a norm, as when we speak of �heart failure� or �engine failure.� What is presupposed in these latter expressions cannot�strictly�be a norm because these are breakdowns or cessations of a mechanism, whether natural or artificial. In this brief essay, I look only at failure strictly so called, where the lights by which it is seen to be a failure are a �norm� in the full and irreducible sense of the term�not a norm that reduces, in the end, to a descriptive tendency of nature or artifice while presenting itself on the surface as a prescriptive and evaluative standard