Resumen de A propòsit de Platón: De la perplejidad al sistema, de Josep Montserrat
The author refutes the interpretation of Matthew 1.18 found in the book, using both contextual and syntactic arguments. With respect to the theory of Ideas, the author disagrees with the book, pointing out that, from the dialogue Meno, where it appears, to its complete development in the Republic, no solution of continuity is found, but rather an unintemunped sequence. The author stresses the global meaning of the Book of Ecclesiastes, and, regarding the notion of God as creator (Republic 597bc, book X), he observes that it is not incongruous, but that this notion has nothing to do with God the creator as found in the Bible, and, as a consequence, they cannot be compared.
