Proof by assumption of the possible in prior analytics 1.15

• Autores: Marko Malink, Jacob Rosen
• Localización: Mind, ISSN-e 1460-2113, Vol. 122, Nº. 488, 2013, págs. 953-986
• Idioma: inglés
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • In Prior Analytics 1.15 Aristotle undertakes to establish certain modal syllogisms of the form XQM. Although these syllogisms are central to his modal system, the proofs he offers for them are problematic. The precise structure of these proofs is disputed, and it is often thought that they are invalid. We propose an interpretation which resolves the main difficulties with them: the proofs are valid given a small number of intrinsically plausible assumptions, although they are in tension with some claims found elsewhere in Aristotle�s modal syllogistic. The proofs make use of a rule of propositional modal logic which we call the possibility rule. We investigate how this rule interacts and coheres with the core elements of the modal syllogistic.