Lewis vs Lewis on the problem of the many

• Autores: Dan López de Sa
• Localización: Synthese, ISSN-e 1573-0964, Vol. 191, Nº. 6, 2014, págs. 1105-1117
• Idioma: inglés
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • Consider a cat on a mat. On the one hand, there seems to be just one cat, but on the other there seem to be many things with as good a claim as anything in the vicinity to being a cat. Hence, the problem of the many. In his 'Many, but Almost One,' David Lewis offered two solutions. According to the first, only one of the many is indeed a cat, although it is indeterminate exactly which one. According to the second, the many are all cats, but they are almost identical to each other, and hence they are almost one. For Lewis, the two solutions do not compete with each other but are mutually complementary, as each one can assist the other. This paper has two aims: to give some reasons against the first of these two solutions, but then to defend the second as a self-standing solution from Lewis's considerations to the contrary