The Impact of Bicameralism on Legislative Production

• Autores: James R. Rogers
• Localización: Legislative studies quarterly, ISSN 0362-9805, Vol. 28, N. 4, 2003, págs. 509-528
• Idioma: inglés
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • It is generally accepted by scholars, as well as by cameral partisans, that adding a second chamber to an otherwise unicameral legislative process will decrease the volume of laws that a legislature enacts. This study challenges the conventional wisdom. First, I offer a simple theoretical argument that shows that when second chambers can originate as well as reject legislation, bicameralism will have an indeterminate impact on legislative production. Second, I provide historical data gathered from the four U.S. states that have experienced cameral transitions. Although very rudimentary, the historical evidence, when coupled with the theoretical argument, raises serious doubt regarding the traditional claim that bicameralism reduces the production of legislation.