A Validation Study for Vinyl Electrical Tape End Matches

• Autores: Maureen J. Bradley, Jennifer M. Gauntt, Andria H. Mehltretter, Preston C. Lowe, Diana M. Wright
• Localización: Journal of forensic sciences, ISSN-e 1556-4029, ISSN 0022-1198, Vol. 56, Nº. 3, 2011, págs. 606-611
• Idioma: inglés
• Texto completo no disponible (Saber más ...)
• Resumen

  • Keywords:forensic science;trace evidence;vinyl electrical tape;end match;error rate;fracture match;physical match;validation study Abstract: Fracture matches are considered the strongest conclusion in the forensic examination of rigid materials, such as glass, metal, and paint. However, publications that support the fracture matching of polymeric films, such as tape backings, are limited. This study was designed to determine the validity and error rate associated with conducting end-match (fracture match) examinations on vinyl electrical tape. Test designs varied the source roll of tape, test preparer, or mode of separation from the roll. Results indicated that each affected the resulting severed tape ends. The analysts examining the end matches also had an effect on the results. Eight end matches in the study were not identified by the initial analysts and were considered inconclusive. One end match was misidentified, resulting in one false positive and an error rate of 0.049%. These results support a comprehensive physical and chemical tape comparison regardless of indications of an end match.