Trastorno depresivo mayor en México: la relación entre la intensidad de la depresión, los síntomas físicos dolorosos y la calidad de vida
- Autores: Luis Guillermo Ruiz Flores, Ricardo Fernanco Colín Piana, Irma Sauyen Corlay Noriega, Maria del Carmen Lara Muñoz, Héctor J. Dueñas Tentori
- Localización: Salud mental, ISSN 0185-3325, Vol. 30, Nº. 2, 2007, págs. 25-32
- Idioma: español
- Enlaces
-
Resumen
- español
Antecedentes:
El Trastorno Depresivo Mayor (TDM) es una enfermedad asociada a síntomas de naturaleza emocional, vegetativos y físicos; entre éstos se encuentran los de naturaleza dolorosa. La enfermedad muestra una alta prevalencia y se estima que hacia el año 2020 se convertirá en la segunda causa de discapacidad. El diagnóstico del TDM se dificulta debido a la alta frecuencia de los síntomas físicos dolorosos, y se presenta hasta en 76% de los pacientes. En este informe presentamos un estudio observacional prospectivo, encaminado a examinar el perfil clínico de pacientes mexicanos no hospitalizados, que presentan TDM, para determinar la relación entre la intensidad de su depresión, los síntomas físicos dolorosos asociados y la calidad de vida.
Método:
Se reclutaron pacientes que presentaran un episodio actual de TDM, con duración menor a dos años, tratados con antidepresivos y libres de síntomas de depresión por lo menos dos meses previos al episodio actual. Se excluyeron pacientes resistentes al tratamiento con antidepresivos o con otro diagnóstico de enfermedad psiquiátrica. Los pacientes (n=313) con TDM fueron clasificados de acuerdo a la presencia (SFD+) de síntomas físicos dolorosos, asociados a la depresión y se utilizó el Inventario de Síntomas Somáticos (SSI), con base en una puntuación ≥ 2 para los correspondientes apartados del SSI con referencia al dolor. Los pacientes con puntuación < 2 se clasificaron con ausencia de síntomas físicos dolorosos (SFD-). Se empleó una Escala Visual Análoga (VAS o Visual Analog Scale) para medir la intensidad del dolor, así como la Escala para Depresión de Hamilton con 17 apartados (HAMD17), la Escala de Impresión Clínica Global en el apartado de Severidad (CGI-S), para calificar la severidad de la depresión, así como la Escala de Calidad de Vida en la Depresión (QLDS), para evaluar el estado de bienestar subjetivo.
Resultados:
Los grupos de pacientes SDF+ y SDF- resultaron comparables en las variables socio-demográficas y en la historia de la enfermedad. El 73.7% de los pacientes reportaron síntomas físicos dolorosos. La puntuación promedio en la HAMD17 (27.1) en los pacientes SFD+ fue significativamente mayor (p<0.0001) que para los pacientes SFD- (23.8), pero no hubo diferencias significativas en las subescalas central, Maier y de retardo; las puntuaciones de la CGI-S fueron similares entre los grupos, 4.6 y 4.5, respectivamente (p>0.05). Los síntomas dolorosos más frecuentes, y de mayor intensidad, medidos en escalas de cinco puntos, con puntaciones promedio sobre 2.96, fueron: dolor muscular (84.9%), dolor cervical (84.2%) y cefalea (83.5%). Los pacientes SFD+ tuvieron dolor más intenso en todas las VAS (p<0.0001) con percepciones mayores al doble que el grupo SFD-. Además, se registraron puntuaciones promedio, significativamente mayores en la QLDS (p<0.001) que se traducen en una calidad de vida más pobre al compararlos con el grupo SFD-. En la primer consulta con su psiquiatra, los pacientes eran tratados con psicoterapia (27.9%), antidepresivos (37.3%), ansiolíticos (28.6%) y analgésicos (9.7%), sin diferencias estadísticas entre los grupos de pacientes.
Conclusión:
Se confirma una alta prevalencia de SFD+ en pacientes con TDM. El aumento en la intensidad del dolor está asociado con mayores puntuaciones en HAMD17, pero no en CGI-S; esta disparidad en la calificación de ambas escalas permite establecer que es fundamental considerar en la valoración clínica las manifestaciones emocionales y físicas como los componentes importantes del TDM; ya que podemos concluir que el juicio clínico del psiquiatra mexicano difiere en su impresión general, con los resultados que obtiene en el mismo paciente, mediante una entrevista semi-estructurada. Cefalea, lumbalgia y dolor cervical caracterizan los síntomas dolorosos de la depresión, con base en su alta prevalencia y mayor gravedad. Los síntomas psicológicos del TDM responden al uso de antidepresivos, pero ya que los SFD+ no responden hasta la remisión, la eficacia del tratamiento antidepresivo puede no ser óptima debido a una falla en el manejo de estos SFD+.
- English
Background:
Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) is a disease associated to emotional, vegetative and physical symptoms, including for the latter those pain-related symptoms. MDD has a high prevalence rate with a substantial burden of illness, and it expected that by 2020 it will become the second cause of world disability. The diagnosis of MDD is difficult due to the high prevalence of painful physical symptoms, and also due to the fact these symptoms are more evident that the embedded emotional ones. Over 76% of patients with MDD, report painful physical symptoms observed, like headache, abdominal pain, back pain and unspecific-located pain; observing these symptoms can even predict depression severity. In addition, the likelihood of psychiatric disease increases, importantly, with the number of physical symptoms observed; moreover, the remission of physical symptoms predicts the complete remission in MDD. We present an observational, prospective study to examine the clinical profile of Mexican outpatients suffering MDD and determine the relationship between depression severity, painful physical symptoms in quality of life and depression.
Methods:
Adult patients with current episodes of MDD, treated with antidepressants were included. MDD was defined according to the criteria of the Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - 4th Edition (DSM-IV) or in the International Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 10th Revision (ICD-10). Patients should have been free of depression symptoms prior to the current episode for at least 2 months. Duration of current episode should not exceed two years. Treatment-resistant patients and those with other psychiatric diagnosis were excluded. Treatment-resistance was defined as: a) a failure to respond to treatment when two different antidepressants were employed at therapeutic doses for at least four weeks each, b) when the subject was previously treated with IMAO inhibitors, c) when electro-convulsive therapy (ECT) was previously employed. Other exclusion criteria comprise previous or current diagnosis of schizophrenia, schizophreniform or schizoaffective disorder, bipolar disorder, dementia or mental impairment. Patients were selected in 34 centers in Mexico.
Patients were classified according to the presence (SFD+) or absence (SFD-) of painful physical symptoms using the Somatic Symptom Inventory (SSI); SFD+ was defined as scores ≥ 2 for the pain-related items in the SSI (items 2, 3, 9, 14, 19, 27 and 28). Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) quantified pain severity (cervical pain, headache, back pain, shoulder pain, interference of pain in daily activities and vigil-time with pain). HAMD17 and CGI-S determined depression severity, while the Quality of Life in Depression Scale (QLDS) quantified subjective well-being.
Linear regression models were employed to compare groups for VAS, HAMD17, CGI-S, and QLDS, to fit the confusions or clinical predictors when needed. Proportions between groups were established with Fisher exact test or logistic regression. Significance levels were established at 0.005 due to the observational nature of the study. In the result tables, standard deviation (SD) is reported as a variation around the mean value as Mean ± SD, and 95% confidence intervals are denoted 95% IC.
Results:
A total of 313 patients were enrolled in the study. All of the enrolled patients were Mexican, almost them were women and had at least a previous MDD episode. Painful physical symptoms were reported by 73.7% of patients, these patients were classified into the SFD+ group. Neither statistical nor clinical significant differences between the SFD+ and SFD- groups were found when analyzing socio-demographic variables (age, gender, ethnical origin) and disease history variables (number of previous episodes of MDD, in the last 24 months, duration of current episode).
At baseline, patients had a CGI-S mean score of 4.6 and HAMD17 of 26.3. HAMD17 mean score (27.1) in SFD+ patients was significantly higher (p<0.0001) than the SFD- patients (23.8), but nonsignificant differences between groups were found for the subscales central, Maier & retard. CGI-S scores were similar between SFD+ and SFD-; 4.6 and 4.5 respectively (p>0.05). Prevalent painful physical symptoms were also the most painful, when a five-point scale was employed to measure severity, and comprised muscular pain (84.9%), cervical pain (84.2%) and headache (83.5%). SFD+ patients had higher pain severity in all VAS scales (p<0.0001), with perceived severity scores twice as large when compared to SFDgroup. In particular, the global pain VAS reported average values of 49.0 and 19.7 for the SFD+ and SFD- groups respectively.
Patients came to the first psychiatric consultation treated with psychotherapy (27.9%), antidepressants (37.3%), anxiolytics (28.6%) and analgesics (9.7%); more than 50% of all patients were not taking any drugs or receiving psychotherapy for treatment of MDD at baseline. Analgesics were used only by 9.7% of patients for the treatment of painful physical symptoms in their current MDD episode. No significant differences between groups were found when comparing the use of psychotherapy, antidepressants, anxiolytics, antipsychotics, mood stabilizers or analgesics. Quality of life was poor for all patients, but significantly worse in the SFD+ group than in the SFD- group (QLDS scores of 23.2 and 20.0 respectively, p<0.001).
Discussion: The diagnosis and symptoms manifestation can be influenced by local socio-cultural factors, in particular cultural differences are associated with the prevalence of painful physical symptoms, but this finding is not consistent. The results of this study can be extrapolated to the MDD Mexican population, as selection criteria comprised only operative diagnosis criteria, and not enrollment into the study took place due to the presence of painful physical symptoms. Patients included into the study presented a moderate to severe disease as measured with the HAMD17 scores. The high prevalence of painful physical symptoms in patients with depression was confirmed in this study; it has been reported the patients report pain-related symptoms as the main (even the only) symptom when consulting general practitioners. Painful physical symptoms in MDD include headache, cervical pain, back pain or neck pain; the presence of painful physical symptoms in depression is associated to higher intakes medication, but in this study more than 50% of subjects were not receiving any treatment, including psychotherapy.
The treatment of MDD is by no means optimal, as only 30%- 40% of these patients reach complete remission of symptoms with their first antidepressant. Psychological symptoms respond to antidepressant treatment, but in general, this is not the case for the physical symptoms. The lack of efficacy can be explained as a failure in the treatment of these painful physical symptoms. Resolving these symptoms is even a predictor for the complete remission of MDD; the evidence might suggest that treatment of emotional and physical manifestations of depression could improve successful-treatment rates.
Conclusion: As found in other reports, a high prevalence of painful physical symptoms was found in MDD patients. Increase in pain severity is associated with higher HAMD17 scores but not CGI-S scores; this discrepancy in the final rates obtained with both scales suggests that both emotional and physical dimensions of MDD should be considered when the clinical assessment is performed. We concluded that clinical judgment of Mexican psychiatrists differs between their global impression and a semi-structured interview in the same patient and therefore is fundamental that the clinical evaluation consists of both emotional and physical manifestations as important components of MDD.
- español
