Is Hyperpluralism Compatible with Dualist Constitutionalism? On Alessandro Ferrara’s Conception of Multivariate Democratic Polity
- Autores: Italo Testa
- Localización: Jura Gentium: Rivista di filosofia del diritto internazionale e della politica globale, ISSN-e 1826-8269, Vol. 14, Nº. 1 (The Prospect for Liberal-Democracy in Troubled Times: A Symposium on Alessandro Ferrara’s The Democr), 2017, págs. 80-95
- Idioma: italiano
- Enlaces
-
Resumen
In this essay I first set out the advantages the “multivariate democratic polity” framework proposed by Ferrara offers in comparison to other more consensus-basednotions of democratic legitimacy. Secondly, I highlight some ambiguities concerning the meta-theoretical status of this frame, since it is not clear whether it consists of an adaptive realistic description, or otherwise is a normative argument. Thirdly, I cast some doubts on the compatibility between the multivariate frame and the “dualist conception of democratic constitutionalism” adopted by Ferrara, since the latter seems too indebted to the domestic analogy, and to a consensus-based model of legitimacy. Finally, I argue that the dualist approach does not seem a convenient way to include citizenship in deliberative processes, and the question of the emergence of a transnational demos should rather be reconsidered as crucial for this purpose.
